Most Read
    Image 01 Image 02 Image 03

    For this selfie, I stood accused of cultural “appropriation”

    For this selfie, I stood accused of cultural “appropriation”

    On the modern campus chock full of microaggression bureaucracies and monitoring, no gesture no matter how small escapes scrutiny.

    An excellent Open Letter to the President of the Vassar College from a Vassar alumnus, published in the student newspaper, is a must read as to what happened when I spoke at Vassar on “hate speech” and free speech. President Elizabeth Bradley’s response is here.

    That letter exchange was the subject of my post, Alum to Vassar College President: “You owe Professor Jacobson a public apology”, which has even more detailed background.

    That letter exchange also caused me to go back and look at a letter from the Executive Board of the Vassar Student Association (the student government) to Vassar’s President, demanding my appearance be cancelled. After lodging a series of accusations against me, the VSA letter concluded:

    …. We strongly urge you, on account of students undergoing serious and real pain, to take our words and ideas seriously, and work towards breaching the contract, ultimately preventing him from coming to campus on Wednesday. On account of the timeframe under which we are operating, we urge the College to undertake speedy and urgent action, as outlined in the beginning of this communication, for the wellbeing of our community. We also urge you to denounce the sentiments and ideologies underlying these types of events, instrumentalizing the language of“free speech” to allow a platform for hate .

    We urge you to think critically about these things. Rather than just engaging the abstract, we urge you to understand how these ideas have physical implications for the safety and well-being of real students on this campus . Ideas are not merely esoteric concepts; they have historically (and presently) been used to silence and justify extreme violence. William Jacobson’s rhetoric and worldview is an illustrative example of where we locate this violence; this is not “free speech.” This is sanctioned violence hiding behind the veneer of liberalism.

    The VSA Executive Board

    The letter was widely circulated on campus. To her credit, Vassar’s President did not cancel the appearance.

    I’m not going to publish the entire VSA letter, since it contains numerous inaccuracies and distortions. But one accusation was so absurd as to be worthy of highlight to illustrate the intolerance that has swept so many campuses.

    The VSA and/or other student groups put together a research team to scour my writings at Legal Insurrection to back up their argument that my appearance should be cancelled. One of the examples they used in their letter to the president referred to my post, All is proceeding as dreaded — A follow up to my DREAD-ful 9th Blog Anniversary post.

    The post utilized the image that is the featured image to this post.

    It was a selfie I took at the Cornell “Take A Knee” Faculty Protest. When I took the selfie, I intended simply to show that I was standing while others knelt, my way of protesting the protest without disrupting my colleagues doing their thing.

    But when I saw the selfie, I realized that I captured two white people standing behind me with their fists in the air during the moment of silence and kneeling. I have no idea, and don’t care, who they are or whether they are faculty, staff or community members. But it struck me as somewhat humorous to have two obviously “woke” “virtue signaling” not-exactly-young white people raising their fists this way, as if they were Tommie Smith and John Carlos, with me in the foreground.

    Referring to that post and featured image, I stood accused by the VSA Executive Board in their letter demanding my appearance be cancelled of cultural “appropriation” and disrespect for the civil rights movement:

    “He utilizes a picture in which two white people appear to be raising their fists in the same symbolic manner as the Black Panther Party, this is clear appropriation and disrespect of the Civil Rights movement”

    Of course, there’s nothing about the photo that is a cultural appropriation by me, or disrespectful to the Civil Rights movement. I wasn’t the one with my fist in the air, it was the two “woke” attendees participating in the protest.

    And even if I were the one raising my fist, who’s to say raising a fist in the air is the exclusive property of the Black Panther or Civil Rights movements? We all share symbols and speech and mannerisms from others. It’s what happens in a healthy, tolerant society. But on the modern campus chock full of microaggression bureaucracies and monitoring, no gesture no matter how small escapes scrutiny.

    But there’s a bigger picture here.

    It’s something we are seeing more and more on college campuses. The intent of the speaker or alternative explanations don’t matter. It’s the feelings of those hearing or seeing the speech that controls. If students seeing that image view it as appropriation, then it’s appropriation. It’s a way of enforcing ideological uniformity.

    A comment to the Open Letter put it succinctly:

    … I don’t know what happened to Vassar but the situation is out of control and scary. The intolerance for others who do not hold the same beliefs is frightening.”

    DONATE

    Donations tax deductible
    to the full extent allowed by law.

    Comments



     
     0 
     
     4
    Cicero of Arpinum | December 11, 2017 at 7:47 am

    They’re professional students at Vassar are worse than “snowflakes”; they are probably ignorant of the observation made by Bonaparte that “There are limits to genius; there are none to stupidity”.

    L’Empereur, two centuries ago, described them to a T.


     
     0 
     
     0
    gourdhead | December 11, 2017 at 8:07 am

    It’s right outside NY City, so what do you expect?


     
     0 
     
     3
    DINORightMarie | December 11, 2017 at 8:09 am

    The Communists used that raised-fist first, starting at least as far back as 1917, all for “the workers” – “Workers of the world, unite!” You didn’t do anything wrong. And frankly, neither did these brainwashed leftists behind you. Cultural appropriation – please!

    These children need to have an adult call them out on their irrational, defamatory accusations and facile arguments.

    I would love to think there is a college administrator, somewhere, who would both publicly and line-by-line in writing dismantle their “arguments” and tell them they failed the semester and/or on academic probation because they are incapable of using higher-level thinking, as their collective diatribe displayed.

    Ah, for the days where higher-level academics meant higher-level, open-minded thinking, rational thought, and true education. The 1960’s mantra to “open your mind” failed, miserably.

    (For those interested, read this from The London Telegraph: Sixties liberalism swept away our shared sense of decency and this Getty clip of Sixties protesters.)


     
     0 
     
     2
    Exiliado | December 11, 2017 at 9:00 am

    In any case, cultural appropriation IS A GOOD THING.
    It has been happening since the origins of men, and it will continue to happen.
    Examples of the benefits of cultural appropriation abound, and are evident to anyone with a minimum of education and intelligence.

    Quick examples:
    Music: Rock & Roll and the myriad of sub-genres spawned from it.
    Peforming Arts, Entertainment: It’s been a quite an upgrade from court jesters and tribe storytellers to 4D IMAX.
    Cuisine: Wholly Guacamole!
    Architecture: Sad that in some parts of the world they still build huts out of grass and dung. Thankfully, there has been a lot of progress moving towards bricks, steel and concrete.
    Human Rights: Interesting than in certain parts of the world it’s still OK to own people, or to stone people to death, or to … you get it, don’t you? Hopefully there will be more of this appropriation.
    Mathematics: Presented without comment.
    Sports: Presented without comment.
    Religion: Presented without comment.
    Medicine: Presented without comment.
    The Blue Jeans: Presented without comment.

    It’s what we do. As cultures interact, we appropriate the best elements of one another. There’s nothing wrong with that. We have to be thankful for cultural appropriation.
    It takes a special kind of stupid (libtard stupid?) to wage war against cultural appropriation.
    And it’s terrifying that the practice is actually catching on.


    Leave a Comment

    Leave a Reply

    You must be logged in to post a comment.

    Notify me of followup comments via e-mail (or subscribe without commenting.)

    Font Resize
    Contrast Mode
    Send this to a friend