Most Read
    Image 01 Image 02 Image 03

    Add Boston Marathon Bombing to pile of Failed Eliminationist Narratives

    Add Boston Marathon Bombing to pile of Failed Eliminationist Narratives

    It started with Bill Sparkman, the part-time Census worker who went missing and then was found dead, setting off an avalanche of mainstream media and left-blogosphere accusations that he was the victim of anti-government “right-wing” hate.  It turned out that Sparkman killed himself, but there were few if any apologies coming.

    The Sparkman accusations were based on nothing more than a desire to demonize the newly formed and rapidly growing Tea Party movement as terrorists and un-American.  It was as if they were hoping for an act of Tea Party violence.

    Yet there was a theory behind the madness, the Eliminationist Narrative created by Dave Neiwart of Crooks and Liars about an “eliminationist” radical right seeking to dehumanize and eliminate political opposition.  It was a play on the over-used narrative of Richard Hofstadter’s “paranoid style” in American politics.

    The Eliminationist Narrative was aided and abetted by an abuse of the term “right-wing” to include groups who are the opposite of conservatism and the Tea Party movement.

    In the case of Sparkman, the accusations were just Another Failed Eliminationist Narrative.  And the Eliminationist Narrative would fail time and time again:

    We can now add the Boston Marathon Bombing to the pile.  The wild speculation that there was a Tea Party or “right-wing” connection proved false.

    It turns out two Muslim Chechens apparently inspired by jihadist videos and ideology turned on the country which welcomed them with open arms.

    Just another Failed Eliminationist Narrative, for which there will be no apologies.

    CNN Wolf Blitzer blames anti-tax group or tea party for Boston Marathon explosion:

    CNN National Security Analyst Warns Of ‘Right-Wing Extremists’ Behind Boston Bombings:

    ABC Speculates: Was Boston ‘Homegrown Terror?’ Features Mark Potok on ‘Extreme Right’

    Chris Matthews: ‘Normally’ Domestic Terrorists ‘Tend to Be on the Right’:

    CNN: Pressure Cooker Bomb ‘Right-Wing’ Signature:

    An article published on CNN’s website makes an unproven claim that pressure cooker bombs like the ones used at the Boston Marathon terror attack are a “signature” of “right-wing extremists.”

    The article says (emphasis added) :

    A senior U.S. counterterrorism investigator told CNN that pressure cooker bombs have also been a signature of extreme right-wing individuals in the United States who he said tend to revel in building homemade bombs.

    This specific claim that “pressure cooker bombs have also been a signature of extreme right-wing individuals in the United States” appears to be completely unsubstantiated. Not a single example is given even in the CNN story itself of anyone other than al-Quadea using a pressure cooker bomb.

    MSNBC Brings On Harvard Professor To Suspect ‘Far-Right’ May Be Responsible For Boston Attack

    NPR Journalist: Boston Terrorist Attack Likely Right-Wingers Celebrating Columbine or Hitler’s Birthday:


    Donations tax deductible
    to the full extent allowed by law.


    […] It wasn’t so much an argument based on facts as a hope based on politics, most clearly by David Sirota at, but he was far from alone, Add Boston Marathon Bombing to pile of Failed Eliminationist Narratives. […]

    […] With Prime Minister Stephen Harper at the helm, the Conservative Party majority gets it done again. This is the second major attack that was thwarted. We are not serious about national security here, though. We want to hug the terrorists. We want to give them trials and lawyers. We want to ask them about root causes and feelings. That’s the Democrat way. Democrats think that only married, Bible-believing small business owning Tea Party conservatives who served in the Armed Forces can be domestic terrorists. They think that William Lane Craig is more likely to be a terrorist than KSM. That’s what they believe. […]

    Leave a Comment

    Leave a Reply

    You must be logged in to post a comment.

    Notify me of followup comments via e-mail (or subscribe without commenting.)

    Font Resize
    Contrast Mode
    Send this to a friend