Most Read
    Image 01 Image 02 Image 03

    “We” never believed them, only “you” did

    “We” never believed them, only “you” did

    Joel Brinkley, currently a Professor at Stanford who spent most of his career as a foreign correspondent for The New York Times, has a column in the San Francisco Chronicle titled Islamists in Egypt, Libya, Tunisia not democratic.

    The thesis of the column is that Westerners who took Islamists at their word that they would promote democracy and freedom as part of the Arab Spring were fooled.  Brinkley counts himself among those fooled:

    Ever since Islamists took office in Tunisia, Libya and Egypt, they have been  trying to convince us that they are advocates of moderation, democracy, women’s  rights and individual freedoms. And most people in the West, after jubilantly  watching the Arab Spring’s amazing revolutions last year, wanted to believe  them.

    But now we can see that these Islamic groups are taking us for fools…

    We should never have believed them.

    We” never believed them and “we” were not fooled.  Only “you” and the cheerleaders at The NY Times like Roger Cohen believed them:

    Already we hear the predictable warnings from Israel’s prime minister, Benjamin Netanyahu: This could be Iran 1979, a revolution for freedom that installs the Islamists. But this is not 1979, and Egypt’s Facebook-adept youth are not lining up behind the Muslim Brotherhood, itself scarcely a band of fanatics.

    We” never believed that — absent an orderly transition — the Google Guy and other Western-oriented relative-secularists had any chance of survival.

    “Your” former colleagues at The NY Times deceived their readers:

    Sheik Qaradawi, a popular television cleric whose program reaches an audience of tens of millions worldwide, addressed a rapt audience of more than a million Egyptians gathered in Tahrir Square to celebrate the uprising and honor those who died….

    On Friday, he struck themes of democracy and pluralism, long hallmarks of his writing and preaching….

    Scholars who have studied his work say Sheik Qaradawi has long argued that Islamic law supports the idea of a pluralistic, multiparty, civil democracy.

    “You” were surprised.  “We” are not.

    “We” have nothing for which to apologize.  “You” do.

    Not that it will make any difference at this point.


    Donations tax deductible
    to the full extent allowed by law.


    Islam is an imperial religion realized in various left-wing ideologies.

    BannedbytheGuardian | April 14, 2012 at 4:53 pm

    Bring back Winnie!

    He hated Arabs Indians Russians Germans Ottomans & Tories. Not too keen on the French either .

    […] Prof. William A. Jacobson warns Prof. Joel Brinkley, and others, to be very careful when applying the “We” word in this matter… […]

    […] Told. You. So. Posted on April 14, 2012 5:56 pm by Bill Quick » “We” never believed them, only “you” did – Le·gal In&mi… Joel Brinkley, currently a Professor at Stanford who spent most of his career as a […]

    Leave a Comment

    Leave a Reply

    You must be logged in to post a comment.

    Notify me of followup comments via e-mail (or subscribe without commenting.)

    Font Resize
    Contrast Mode
    Send this to a friend