Most Read
    Image 01 Image 02 Image 03

    Does Dane County Sheriff have conflict in Prosser-Bradley Investigation?

    Does Dane County Sheriff have conflict in Prosser-Bradley Investigation?

    As mentioned yesterday, Dane County Sheriff David Mahoney is leading an investigation into allegations that Justice David Prosser put a “chokehold” on Justice Ann Walsh Bradley, and counter-allegations that Bradley initiated physical contact.

    One of the witnesses was Chief Justice Shirley Abrahamson, who has a long history of verbal conflict with Prosser. 

    Sheriff Mahoney was a campaign supporter of Abrahamson.  According to Fairly Conservative, a Wisconsin blog, Sheriff Mahoney appeared in a campaign advertisement for her (in the initial still screen shot, and at the 0:18 mark):

    Another blog confirmed in 2009 that it was Sheriff Mahoney in the campaign ad, as does someone familiar with Wisconsin politics. (Yes, just before Sheriff Mahoney in the video is Judge Maryann Sumi.)

    In such a highly politicized case, does it make sense for Sheriff Mahoney to be leading the investigation, considering that Abrahamson is one of the witnesses?

    Even assuming (which I do) that the Sheriff and his staff will do a completely professional investigation, doesn’t the Sheriff’s political connection to Abrahamson raise an appearance of bias problem? Shouldn’t the investigator be someone with no political connection to any of the Justices? 

    I e-mailed Shefiff Mahoney last night asking for comment both to confirm his appearance in the video and as to any possible conflict.  I have not heard back, but will update this post if he responds.

    (This issue was brought to my attention by commenter Dad29, and by Steve Eggleston)

    Update:  Sheriff Mahoney has more political conflicts.  Per JSOnline, he endorsed Prosser’s opponent, JoAnne Kloppenburg and shares the same campaign manager as Kloppenburg.

    Update No. 2. Thanks to a reader in Wisconsin for forwarding me this link from The Wisconsin Reporter of a statement issued by Sheriff Mahoney that he will play no personal role in the investigation.


    Donations tax deductible
    to the full extent allowed by law.


    Carol Herman | June 28, 2011 at 11:29 pm

    A yelling match doesn’t qualify. Someone posted (elsewhere) that Hugo Black went and hit Felix Frankfurter while the US Supreme Court was in session. Frankfurter probably deserved the smack down.

    Here? A suspect that abrahamson thought if she called this story into friendly journalists she’d ruin Prosser’s career. No such thing happened. As a matter of fact, just the opposite.

    As to the ad agency that did the ad for abrahamson, I bet they don’t come forward and ask to be identified. It won’t be on any resume addressed to other politicians in the “hire me” vein. “I have experience” department.

    Prosser just has to keep writing his decision opinions in ways that are solid. How abrahamson, bradley and sumi, ignored this truth is just beyond comprehension. But you could teach this just for comical effect, no?

    teapartydoc | June 29, 2011 at 10:05 am

    I am sooooooo glad I don’t live in WI. A poisoned well and has been that way for over a hundred years.

    Leave a Comment

    Leave a Reply

    You must be logged in to post a comment.

    Notify me of followup comments via e-mail (or subscribe without commenting.)

    Font Resize
    Contrast Mode
    Send this to a friend