You Can’t Pick Your Relatives, Or Who Links To You
There are many cheap tricks used against bloggers.
Perhaps the most common is to attribute the views expressed in comments to the blogger. The problem there is that the nature of a comment section is to give people other than the blogger the chance to express an opinion, so one has nothing to do with the other. In addition, as happened to Sarah Palin, sometimes comments are planted for the deliberate purpose of making the blogger (or website organizer) look bad.
There is yet another cheap trick, which is to attribute the views of those who link to the blogger to the blogger.
The Southern Poverty Law Center has used this trick by claiming that linkage by a racist or white supremacist website is evidence that the content linked and the blogger linked reflect the views of the linking website. With regard to Pamela Geller SPLC wrote:
“Her comments were so incendiary, in fact, that several neo-Nazi organizations even ignored the fact that she is Jewish and published her diatribes.”
Geller’s rebuttal to SPLC’s charges is here, but that is somewhat besides the point. If SPLC is going to make the case that views expressed are racist or white supremacist, the mere linkage by racist or white supremacist organizations is not enough, or if it were, Glenn Greenwald would be guilty as well.
On November 13, 2010, I was harshly critical of Greenwald for his post Eric Cantor’s Pledge of Allegiance in which Greenwald suggested that Eric Cantor (R-Va) was disloyal to the United States and had instead pledged allegiance to Israel. Greenwald responded on November 20, (wrongly) claiming that I was accusing him of being anti-semitic. In preparing my further response, I noticed that Greenwald’s original post had been reposted at Stormfront, a white supremacist website.
I could have used the Stormfront reposting against Greenwald, but that would have been as wrong as what the SPLC did to Geller.
Both Greenwald and Geller (and I and every other blogger) deserve their writings to be praised or criticized based on the only thing the writer can control, namely, the content. We are not responsible for people who comment on it, or link to it.
Pulling The Financial Mask Off The SPLC, Slowly
SPLC Demonizes Supporters of Traditional Marriage
SPLC To Apologize to Prof. Guenter Lewy For False Accusations
Follow me on Twitter, Facebook, and YouTube
Visit the Legal Insurrection Shop on CafePress!
Donations tax deductible
to the full extent allowed by law.
For SPLC, it's all about the Benjamins:
Leave a Comment