Most Read
    Image 01 Image 02 Image 03

    Which Seat Would Cass Sunstein Fill?

    Which Seat Would Cass Sunstein Fill?

    Cass Sunstein has a problem if he wants to get on the Supreme Court. It’s not his intellect or credentials. According to Elena Kagan, also a contender for the high court, “Cass Sunstein is the pre-eminent legal scholar of our time — the most wide-ranging, the most prolific, the most cited, and the most influential.”

    A shoe-in shoo-in for the Court? Maybe, but maybe not now. The reason? It is not clear which “seat” he would fill. Perhaps recognizing the problem, Sunstein argues for “intellectual diversity” rather than diversity based on demographics:

    The question of diversity on the Supreme Court has been with us for a long time. In the past, there was a de facto “Jewish seat” on the Supreme Court, first filled by Louis Brandeis and then for many years by Felix Frankfurter, who was succeeded by Arthur Goldberg, followed in turn by Abe Fortas. (Justices Ruth Bader Ginsburg and Stephen Breyer are both Jewish.) There is, in effect, an African American seat today. Thurgood Marshall was replaced by Clarence Thomas and, unless another African American is named to the court first, when Thomas leaves he will almost surely be replaced by an African American….

    Unfortunately, all this focus on demographics misses the most important point. What the court most needs is intellectual diversity. It should have people with a range of perspectives, different kinds of knowledge and different points of view. For many questions that come before the court, expertise is important, and it is impossible for anyone to be an expert in everything. The court has greatly benefited from having Breyer, a specialist in copyright law, and Justice Antonin Scalia, a specialist in separation of powers. And for the most important questions, internal differences are crucial because they sharpen arguments and increase the likelihood that the court will get it right.

    Sunstein’s argument is not a self-serving attempt to get Obama’s nomination. The argument quoted above was made with regard to George Bush’s nomination of John Roberts in 2005. But the point remains true to this day. It is unclear which “seat” Sunstein would fill, particularly if new seats are assigned based on race, gender or ethnicity.

    But it is clear that Sunstein would fill an intellectual seat and be a formidable voice on the Court to rival John Roberts. That may not be enough.

    ——————————————–
    Follow me on Twitter and Facebook

    DONATE

    Donations tax deductible
    to the full extent allowed by law.

    Comments


    well, let’s not allow the fact that sustein is self-interested to obscure the fact that he is making sense. The entire idea of the diversity argument is that if you put together alot of different races, genders etc. you will get different views. But what ends up happening in reality is you get a rainbow of liberal voices, who only vary in whether they are to the left or right of marx. Diversity of people was supposed to result in diversity of viewpoint, but in fact the left hates diversity of viewpoint.

    Except it won’t actually work anyway. You can’t create liberal and conservative seats on the supreme court and expect any future president to honor that distinction. But sustein would make much more sense in the context of, say, university admissions.

    Sorry to be a quibbler, but it’s “shoo-in,” not “shoe-in.” In its original meaning, it referred to a horse-race that was rigged such that all that had to be done was to “shoo” the winner across the finish line.

    Thanks for the catch.

    I just heard on CNN that our illustrioous DHS secretary is the leading candidate.

    That will make the Gay lobby wet their nappies. But she seems like a complete dolt in her current job.

    You will have to pardon me if I don’t get too outraged over Cass “Second Bill of Rights” Sunstein being hoist with his own petard.


    Leave a Comment

    Leave a Reply

    You must be logged in to post a comment.

    Notify me of followup comments via e-mail (or subscribe without commenting.)

    Font Resize
    Contrast Mode
    Send this to a friend